The Theory of Holes
Barron's Online (08/28/00) Vol. 104, No. 34 p.13; Whitney, John O.
The Securities and Exchange Commission's decision to
cut down on accounting firms doing consulting work for their
audit clients is the opposite of what is needed to improve
auditors' ability to understand and work for their clients,
writes Columbia University business professor John O. Whitney.
Because managers often deliberately cover up bad figures, and
auditing teams can lack the experience to spot such behavior--and
also because accountants are better at working with the past than
the future--it is not unheard of for companies to go bankrupt
shortly after getting a "clean" audit from independent
accountants. At a World Congress of Accountants in 1997, Whitney
proposed that accountants could serve clients better by offering
consulting services as well as accounting and financial services,
but they should stop giving their certification to financial
reports. This would help investors understand that the company
reporting its results, and not the auditing firm, is responsible
for the information in a financial report. In addition, Whitney
says financial reports should be prepared using the SFAS 95
Direct Method for cash flows, Activity Based Costing techniques
for line of business operations, and three-year graphics for key
ratios.