Funding Fun House
CFO (01/03) Vol. 19, No. 1 p.65; McCafferty, Joseph
After three years of declining stock markets following the
bull market of the 1990s, many large companies are finding they will
have to contribute to their underfunded pension funds. Companies
currently experiencing pension losses include Ford Motor Co., Honeywell,
and AMR Corp., and experts note that because some companies have been
unable to defer cash contributions for a year, the coming years will see
many more large companies with deficits in their pension funds. A
Credit Suisse First Boston (CSFB) report estimates that the Standard &
Poor's 500 will report net pension expenses of $15 billion in 2003.
Even though pension plans have been performing poorly for years,
companies became over funded during the bull market, and are just now
beginning to experience the effects of the poor stock market, experts
note. Pension funding has long covered up pension losses and accounting
rules that allow companies to overestimate their pension returns and
delay their pension contributions. A Milliman USA study shows that 50
of the largest U.S. companies estimated they would experience about $54
billion of pension fund gains as profits in 2002, whereas they actually
experienced pension losses of almost $36 billion. The average U.S.
company uses an investment-return rate of 9.2 percent to calculate
pension earnings, but some experts and lawmakers are beginning to see
the advantages of using a more realistic investment-return rate. CSFB
analyst David Zion points out that even the slightest alteration of a
company's return rate can affect income statements by hundreds of
millions of dollars, and proposes recording pension losses and gains at
fair market value instead, forcing companies to declare their pension
funding status on their balance sheets.