Defined Contribution Plan Providers Hurt by Dwindling Fees
Pensions & Investments (11/02) Vol. 30, No. 23 p.3; Jacobius, Arleen
The costs of defined contribution plans have dipped 30
percent since Sept. 11, says a recent study by Boston Research
Group, and while plan sponsors benefit from lower costs, service
providers have seen a 50 percent plunge in revenue. Meanwhile,
profits have fallen for record keepers and other providers in
recent years due to rising expenses and weakening participant
revenue. In fact, the research found that administrative costs
dipped 8.4 percent to $18,354, and equity management costs
dropped 31 percent to $269,997. In terms of providers,
overall charges fell 20 percent for insurers and 31 percent for
mutual funds. Moreover, Robert Wuelfing, president of consulting
firm R.G. Wuelfing & Associates, says the combination of
declining revenue and high costs has made 13 percent of plans
unprofitable, and the industry continues to cut costs to offset
revenue losses. With less money to manage, 401kExchange.com
President Fred Barstein says providers are laying off servicers,
wholesalers, and sales representatives, rather than fund
managers. To survive, providers will need to eliminate
unprofitable clients, implement automated services, and keep
participant accounts for more than the average six years. By
refusing to take new business, Wuelfing believes providers can
concentrate on their sales team and work to control their pricing
and costs, something fewer than 15 percent of providers have
accomplished.