N.A.S.D. Criminal Unit's Activities Face Legal Challenge
New York Times (02/15/01) Vol. 55, No. 3 p.C1; Morgenson, Gretchen
Three years ago, the National Association of Securities
Dealers (NASD) set up a unit to help federal prosecutors with criminal
securities fraud cases. Today, however, this little-known criminal unit
is the one facing scrutiny. D.L. Cromwell Investments, a small New York
Brokerage firm, has filed a federal lawsuit against the NASD's unit.
The firm alleges that the NASD Regulation is acting as an agent of the
United States government. The suit charges that the unit is using its
rules as a private entity to obtain testimony from executives--testimony
that the government could not force on its own. The NASD Regulation,
however, contends that it is a private organization conducting
regulatory functions--which makes it a quasi-government agency. Since
NASD Regulation is viewed as a quasi-government agency by the nation's
court, it is immune from prosecution when sued by a member. When it
enforces its rules, however, NASD maintains that it is a private
organization. The apparent symbiotic relationship between the NASD and
law enforcement officials creates a situation where information may be
improperly shared. According to Martin P. Russo, an attorney
representing Cromwell executives, "This [relationship] can't be
permitted without establishing adequate procedures to prevent the
transfer of information between [NASD Regulation] and the United States
government which would give rise to the potential to violate
constitutional rights."