Tech Firms Hide Payroll Taxes on Employees' Stock Options
Wall Street Journal (09/07/00) Vol. 2, No. 4 p.C1; Mangalindan, Mylene; McGough, Robert
In quarterly earnings announcements, technology
companies such as BEA Systems, Yahoo!, and Cisco Systems, are
highlighting a net-income figure that leaves out the payroll
taxes they must pay to employees when employees exercise their
stock options. By excluding the expense of the payroll taxes,
companies look more profitable, which is necessary for survival
in the heavy stress of today's stock market. The companies
announce their pro-forma earnings at the top of their earnings
releases, and the pro-forma number can either include or exclude
any revenues the company desires, because accounting rules only
apply to the official-income figure that appears later in the
earnings release. Pro-forma earnings are, consequently,
predictably higher than the official-income figure. Some
expenses, such as acquisition costs, are reasonably excluded,
since they are not recurring, and thus would only hamper
investor's understanding of how a business is performing. But
payroll taxes, while representing only a small portion of income
for the companies that leave them out, could greatly effect a
stock price. The SEC is responsible for regulating pro-forma
income, but it does not "have specific rules that go to
presentation of alternative measures of performance," according
to Robert Bayless, chief accountant in the division of
corporation finance, who added that rules against "presenting
misleading or unbalanced information applies to these sorts of
things."